Pfleger Removed From Saint Sabina Again After New Abuse Claim

Father Michael Pfleger, the longtime and often controversial pastor of Saint Sabina Church in Chicago’s Auburn Gresham neighborhood, has been removed from ministry once again after a new allegation of sexual abuse surfaced. The Archdiocese of Chicago announced the decision late Tuesday, stating that Pfleger would step aside pending an investigation into the claim, which involves an incident alleged to have occurred decades ago. Pfleger has denied the accusation, calling it “false and defamatory,” but has agreed to comply with the archdiocese’s process.

This is not the first time Pfleger has faced such allegations. In 2021, he was placed on administrative leave after a separate accusation emerged, only to be reinstated months later when the archdiocese found the claim to be unsubstantiated. That earlier episode created deep divisions within Saint Sabina, with some parishioners staunchly defending their pastor and others calling for greater transparency. The current accusation, which has not been detailed publicly, has reopened those wounds and placed the parish—and the broader Chicago Catholic community—under a harsh spotlight.

A Pattern of Scrutiny and Division

The repeated allegations against Pfleger, a prominent and outspoken activist known for his work on racial justice and gun violence, have complicated his legacy. For decades, he has been a powerful voice in Chicago, but these accusations have created a rift among parishioners and clergy alike. Some see him as a victim of a flawed system, while others believe the church must take a zero-tolerance stance. The Archdiocese has stated it is taking the matter seriously and has removed Pfleger pending a thorough investigation, but has not commented on the specifics of the new allegation.

This development comes at a time when the Catholic Church continues to grapple with the long shadow of the clergy sex abuse crisis. For Saint Sabina, a historically Black parish that has been a cornerstone of activism and community service, the repeated turmoil is particularly painful. The parish has long been a symbol of progressive faith and social justice, and Pfleger has been its most visible leader for decades. His removal, even if temporary, leaves a void in leadership and raises questions about the future direction of the parish and its ministries.

The Archdiocese has stated it will cooperate fully with any civil investigation. Pfleger himself has maintained his innocence, and his supporters have rallied to his defense, citing his lifelong dedication to the community. The situation remains fluid, and the coming weeks will be critical in determining both the legal and ecclesiastical outcomes. For the Chicagoland community, this is not just a story about one priest, but a painful reminder of the ongoing crisis of trust within the Church and the long road to accountability and healing.